Monday, 8 September 2014

Posts 3240 - Self & Peer Grading - org. posting - Panna Majithia & replies

The Impact of Self and Peer Grading on Student Learning by Panna Majithia - Saturday, 6 September 2014, 11:29 PM Self-grading appears to result in increased student learning; peer-grading does not. Many teachers ask students to grade their work or their peers’ work not only to save themselves time, but also because they believe self-grading and peer-grading provide students with another learning opportunity. However, a study published in the January 2006 issue of Educational Assessmentconcludes that self-grading can be a more effective teaching tool than peer grading. Self-grading also can be a better substitute for teacher assessment than peer grading, the researchers found. The researchers looked at the correlation of grades by comparing self- and peer-grading with the test grades that a seventh-grade science teacher assigned to 101 students in four classes. They also measured the impact on learning by analyzing students’ performance on an unannounced second administration of the test a week after self- or peer-grading. “Students who graded their peers’ tests did not gain significantly more than a control group of students who did not correct any papers but simply took the same test again,” the researchers say. “Those students who corrected their own tests improved dramatically.” “When grading others, students awarded lower grades to the best performing students than their teacher did,” they report. While lower performing students tended to inflate their own low scores, the researchers speculate that “students may be more conscientious in grading their own papers than those of a randomly selected, nameless peer, because they have more at stake in making sure their own paper gets graded accurately.” Thoughts? http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/sed/staff/Sadler/articles/Sadler%20and%20Good%20EA.pdf -------------------------------------------------------------------- Reply Re: The Impact of Self and Peer Grading on Student Learning by Houman Sadjadian - Sunday, 7 September 2014, 7:43 AM Thanks Panna for the great discussion, The literature on self assessment and peer assessment is really rich. I do practice self grading when I teach university courses and I truly believe that it promotes learning and I have seen many students with totally wrong expectations which shows their low level of learning. But I think that peer assessment is equally important and we must practice that as well in a way that the students learn to listen to the critiques from their peers or fellow classmates and their colleagues in the future. Learning to be honest and judge honestly is not easy, I, once took part in a self grading activity with some of my friends in school and I saw that they all think their work is awesome and they deserve the best mark, so why should I be honest and give myself a lower mark when they are not doing that and the instructor is not changing the self mark submission! Thanks Houman ----------------------------------------------------------- Re: The Impact of Self and Peer Grading on Student Learning by Marie Blair - Monday, 8 September 2014, 3:57 PM Panna, thanks for introducing this topic. I agree that self-assessment provides another effective way to enhance learning at all levels for those students who are truly interested in learning. Unfortunately there are some students who go to school only to obtain a degree, designation, or certification and to get a job. As grades and the final certification are more important than the learning, I wonder how honest they would be with their self-assessment. Nevertheless, many institutions are advocating for the use of self-assessment to enhance student learning. For example, Cornell University Center of Teaching Excellence provides information on why it is important and how to incorporate self-assessment in learning. They suggest that self-assessment promotes Timely and effective feedback, Academic integrity through student self-reporting, Self-reflection, self-monitoring, self-direction, and motivation. The university of Derby site for Learning Enhancement suggests that self-assessment enables students to “become more aware of the gaps in their knowledge and understanding providing them with feedback on areas to develop, and an opportunity to reflect upon the skills and experience they have gained.” Self-assessment can be facilitated by technological tools and be both reflective and formative. Reflective learning can be done using blogs or e-portfolios where students can write about their experiences and post examples of learning. Formative learning can be achieved by using online self-quizzes and problem-based tests. The Cornell University site suggests that students can submit a cover sheet with their assignments and respond to questions about their learning. http://www.cte.cornell.edu/teaching-ideas/assessing-student-learning/self-assessment.html http://www.derby.ac.uk/lei/tel/assessing-students/self-assessment ---------------------------------------- Re: The Impact of Self and Peer Grading on Student Learning by Bronwyn Brown - Monday, 8 September 2014, 10:23 PM Hi Panna, This topic caught my interest, as I believe peer grading on student learning is as valuable as self grading. I found a Ted Talk YouTube called Daphne Koller: What We're Learning From Online Education, in which she references research called "The Impact of Self-and-Peer-Grading on Student Learning" P. Sadler, E. Good. Educational Assessment (2006), which supports my belief. Daphne Koller Phd is a professor at Stanford and is the co-founder of Coursera. Take a look at the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=U6FvJ6jMGHU Great topic. Thanks for the post. - Bronwyn

No comments:

Post a Comment